Book Review: Bestseller vs. Underrated Gem

What The Plot
Aug 6
4 min read

Updated: Sep 27

In the world of literature, the debate between bestsellers and underrated gems is a lively one. Bestsellers often dominate the shelves, capturing the attention of readers and critics alike. They are the books everyone seems to be talking about. On the other hand, underrated gems quietly wait in the shadows, offering unique stories and perspectives that deserve recognition.

In this post, we will explore the differences between these two categories of books. We will look at examples of each, discuss their merits, and help you decide which type of book might be right for you.

What Makes a Bestseller?

Bestsellers are often defined by their sales figures. These books fly off the shelves, often due to effective marketing, popular authors, or timely themes.

Characteristics of Bestsellers

Wide Appeal: Bestsellers usually have themes that resonate with a large audience. They often tackle universal issues like love, loss, or adventure.
Strong Marketing: Publishers invest heavily in promoting these books. You will see them featured in ads, social media, and even on book club lists.
Established Authors: Many bestsellers come from well-known authors. Readers are more likely to pick up a book from someone they already trust.

Examples of Bestsellers

"Where the Crawdads Sing" by Delia Owens: This novel has captivated millions with its blend of mystery and coming-of-age themes. Its popularity skyrocketed due to word-of-mouth and social media buzz.
"The Midnight Library" by Matt Haig: This book explores the concept of choices and regrets. Its thought-provoking premise has made it a favorite among readers and book clubs.

Both of these books have achieved bestseller status for good reason. They are well-written, engaging, and resonate with a wide audience.

The Allure of Underrated Gems

While bestsellers are easy to find, underrated gems require a bit more digging. These books may not have the same level of marketing or recognition, but they often offer rich narratives and unique perspectives.

Characteristics of Underrated Gems

Unique Storylines: Underrated gems often explore themes that are less mainstream. They can provide fresh insights and experiences.
Hidden Talents: Many underrated authors are emerging voices. Their work may not yet have the visibility it deserves.
Cult Followings: Some underrated books develop a loyal fan base over time. Readers who discover them often feel like they have found a secret treasure.

Examples of Underrated Gems

"The Book of Longings" by Sue Monk Kidd: This novel imagines the life of Jesus' wife, offering a fresh perspective on a well-known story. It has received praise but remains less recognized than many bestsellers.
"The Lying Game" by Ruth Ware: While Ruth Ware is gaining popularity, this particular book often gets overshadowed by her other works. It is a gripping psychological thriller that deserves more attention.

These underrated gems may not be on every bestseller list, but they offer compelling stories that can resonate deeply with readers.

The Reader's Dilemma: Bestseller or Underrated Gem?

Choosing between a bestseller and an underrated gem can be challenging. Each has its own appeal and can satisfy different reading moods.

When to Choose a Bestseller

Looking for a Quick Read: Bestsellers are often page-turners. If you want something engaging and easy to read, a bestseller might be the way to go.
Joining Conversations: If you want to discuss your reading with friends or online communities, bestsellers are often the books everyone is talking about.
Trusting Established Authors: If you prefer to read books from authors with a proven track record, bestsellers are a safe bet.

When to Choose an Underrated Gem

Seeking Unique Perspectives: If you want to explore themes that are less common, an underrated gem can provide a fresh take.
Enjoying Hidden Treasures: There is something special about discovering a book that few others have read. It can feel like a personal victory.
Supporting Emerging Authors: By choosing underrated gems, you are often supporting new voices in literature. This can be a rewarding experience.

The Balance Between Both Worlds

As a reader, it is essential to find a balance between bestsellers and underrated gems. Each type of book has its own strengths and can enrich your reading experience in different ways.

Tips for Finding the Right Book

Mix It Up: Try alternating between bestsellers and underrated gems. This can keep your reading experience fresh and exciting.
Read Reviews: Look for book reviews that highlight both bestsellers and underrated gems. This can help you discover new titles that you might not have considered.
Join a Book Club: Many book clubs choose a mix of popular and lesser-known titles. This can expose you to a variety of genres and authors.

Final Thoughts: The Joy of Reading

In the end, whether you choose a bestseller or an underrated gem, the most important thing is to enjoy the journey of reading. Each book has the potential to transport you to new worlds, introduce you to fascinating characters, and spark your imagination.

So, the next time you are at the bookstore or browsing online, consider picking up a book that you might not have noticed before. You may just find your next favorite read hiding among the shelves.