Some Choose Darkness by Charlie Donlea — Spoiler-Free Review (5 Stars)
Updated: Aug 11
A Deep Dive into the Thrilling World of Forensic Reconstruction: A Review of Rory Moore's Journey
Quick Synopsis (No Spoilers)
Rory Moore is a forensic re-constructionist—the person who can walk into a cold case and see what everyone else missed. While she’s grappling with her father’s death, she becomes entangled in a case linked to the summer of 1979 in Chicago. During that time, multiple women went missing, and a predator nicknamed “The Thief” left almost nothing behind.
One name keeps surfacing: Angela Mitchell—a young woman whose information may have exposed the killer… before she vanished herself. Now, decades later, the case is reopening at the worst possible time for Rory.
Why I Rated It 5 Stars
This is one of those thrillers that feels cleanly plotted but still manages to stress you out the entire time.
It moves swiftly. Not in a chaotic way—more like every chapter ends with you thinking, wait—what does that mean? Suddenly, you find yourself 80 pages deeper.
2) Rory Moore is the Kind of Main Character I’ll Follow Anywhere.
She’s sharp, a little intense, and wired in a way that makes her both brilliant and complicated. This complexity is exactly what you want when the case is messy.
3) The Past and Present Storyline is Done SO Well.
The 1979 thread adds dread and atmosphere. The present-day investigation has that ticking-clock feeling because this isn’t just a “cold case”—it’s a “this could happen again” case.
4) It’s Dark, but It’s Not Pointless.
This book delves into violence and control, but it also explores what gets ignored, what gets buried, and what eventually claws its way back up.
Vibes / Tropes
Serial killer / cold case
Dual timeline (past + present)
Forensic reconstruction / crime puzzle
Missing women, buried secrets
“Everyone knows something” energy
Content Notes (Heads Up)
This narrative centers on disappearances and violence against women, along with the ripple effects. It’s not gore-for-shock, but it is heavy.
If You Like Dark Thrillers, You’ll Probably Like This
If you enjoy dark, investigative thrillers with a high-concept job—profiling, forensics, and reconstruction—and a case that stretches across decades, this is your lane.
The Emotional Impact of the Story
Reading this book was like stepping into a world where every detail matters. I found myself reflecting on the emotional weight of Rory's journey. The blend of personal loss and professional challenge creates a rich tapestry of human experience.
Character Development and Depth
Rory Moore is not just a forensic reconstructionist; she is a character with layers. Her struggles resonate deeply, making her relatable. I appreciated how the author crafted her character, allowing us to see her vulnerabilities alongside her strengths.
The Setting: Chicago in the Late 1970s
The backdrop of Chicago in 1979 adds a unique flavor to the story. The city’s atmosphere is palpable, and it feels like a character in its own right. The author vividly paints the scene, transporting me back in time.
Themes of Violence and Control
The book does not shy away from the darker aspects of human nature. It explores themes of violence and control, but it also highlights resilience and the quest for truth. These themes linger long after the last page is turned.
Final Thoughts
Rating: ⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️
I finished it and immediately wanted to talk about it (and also triple-check my door locks). This book is a must-read for anyone who loves a gripping thriller that keeps you on the edge of your seat.
GET YOUR BOOK Here
In conclusion, if you're looking for a thrilling ride that combines a compelling narrative with deep emotional undertones, look no further. This book has it all, and I can't wait to see what Rory Moore tackles next.
Comments